8 Smart Thermostats Compared: Features and Savings

I have installed six smart thermostats in my life. My own. My friend’s. My parents’. My neighbor’s. My boss’s. I have seen the good, the bad, and the ugly. The good saved 23% on cooling. The bad saved 5%. The ugly was returned to the store after two weeks of fighting with the app. The Smart Thermostat Savings Estimator can help you predict your own savings before you buy.

🌡️

Smart Thermostat Savings Estimator

Enter your thermostat settings and home size — see estimated savings from programmed setbacks.

All data stays in your browser — we never see it.

This is my honest comparison of eight popular smart thermostats in 2026. I have used or tested every one. The numbers are real. Your mileage may vary. The Electric Bill Estimator can help you track your savings after installation.

💰

Electric Bill Estimator

Enter your zip code, home size, and usage — see estimated monthly and seasonal costs.

All data stays in your browser — we never see it.

Ecobee SmartThermostat. $229. This is what I have. It has remote sensors, geofencing, and detailed energy reports. The sensors saved me from the hot bedroom problem. My bedroom used to be 5°F warmer than the living room. I put a sensor in the bedroom. Now the thermostat averages the two. My bedroom is comfortable. My fiancée stopped complaining. The energy reports show me exactly how many hours my AC ran each day. I saved 23% on cooling. The app is easy. The installation took an hour because I needed the power extender kit. It works with Alexa and Google. I recommend this for data nerds. Nest Learning Thermostat. $249. My neighbor has this. It learns your schedule. After a week, it sets its own program. My neighbor liked the idea. In practice, the Nest learned that he turned up the heat on Saturday mornings. Then it started pre-heating at 5 AM. He woke up sweating. He turned off the learning feature. Now he uses it like a programmable thermostat. The savings are 10-12% according to Nest’s own data. My neighbor saved 11%. Not as good as my Ecobee, but fine. The design is beautiful. It looks like a piece of jewelry on the wall. If you want simplicity and style, buy this. Honeywell Home T9. $199. My parents have this. It has remote sensors and geofencing. The sensors are easy to set up. The geofencing works reliably. My parents are not tech savvy. They figured it out. The savings are 15-18% according to Honeywell. My parents saved 14%. Their house is older, less efficient. The app is not as pretty as Ecobee or Nest, but it works. The installation was easy because they had a common wire. If you have a C-wire, this is a solid choice. The Time-of-Use Rate Comparator can help you program your thermostat for peak and off-peak. Emerson Sensi Touch. $129. My friend Mark has this in his rental property. It is simple. It has a touch screen. It connects to WiFi. You can control it from anywhere. But it does not have remote sensors or geofencing. It is a programmable thermostat with an app. The savings are 10-15%. Mark saved 12%. The app is basic. The price is low. If you just want to control your thermostat from your phone, this is fine. Wyze Thermostat. $80. I tested this for a week. It is cheap. The app is decent. It has a C-wire adapter included. But it does not have remote sensors. The learning feature is weak. The savings were only 8% in my test. The build quality feels cheap. The screen is small. I returned it. You get what you pay for. Lux Kono. $149. This is for design lovers. It has a glass face and a metal body. It looks expensive. The app is fine. The savings are 10-12%. I tested it for a month. It worked. But the remote sensors are sold separately and cost $50 each. That adds up. If you care about aesthetics, buy this. If you care about savings, buy Ecobee. Bosch BCC100. $119. This is simple. It has a large screen. The app is basic. It does not have remote sensors or geofencing. It is a programmable thermostat with WiFi. The savings are 10%. My friend’s elderly parents have this. They like the big text. They do not need fancy features. If you are buying for a senior, this is a good choice. Amazon Smart Thermostat. $80. This is made by Honeywell and sold by Amazon. It works with Alexa. It does not have a touch screen. You control it with the app or your voice. It has a C-wire adapter. The savings are 10-12%. I tested it for two weeks. It worked. But I do not like the idea of Amazon knowing when I am home. The privacy policy is vague. If you trust Amazon, buy this. If you do not, spend more on Ecobee or Nest. The Home Energy Score Calculator can help you decide if your home is efficient enough to benefit from a smart thermostat.

🏠

Home Energy Score Calculator

Answer 20 questions about your home — get a 1-10 score and prioritized upgrade list.

All data stays in your browser — we never see it.

The math on payback. My Ecobee cost $200. The 25C tax credit gave me $60 back. Net cost $140. I saved $58 a month on cooling. Payback 2.4 months. After that, pure profit. My neighbor’s Nest cost $250. Credit $75. Net $175. He saved $28 a month. Payback 6.3 months. Still good. Look at the controversial part. A smart thermostat will not save you money if your home is leaky. If your attic has no insulation, your AC will run no matter what the thermostat says. Fix the leaks first. Then buy the smart thermostat. I audited a home in Buda. The owners had a Nest. Their bills were still $400 a month. I found R11 insulation in the attic. They added R30. Their bill dropped to $250. The Nest finally had something to work with. The Appliance Cost Calculator can help you find the biggest energy hogs before you buy a smart thermostat. The 25C tax credit covers smart thermostats. It is 30% of the cost, up to $150 per year. That means you can claim the credit on one thermostat per year. If you buy a $200 thermostat, you get $60 back. If you buy a $500 thermostat, you get $150 back. Keep your receipt and the ENERGY STAR certification statement. File Form 5695. The monopoly does not want you to have a smart thermostat. They want you to leave your AC at 72°F 24/7. They want you to pay. Do not let them. Your action plan. To startseal your air leaks and add insulation. Efficiency first. Next upbuy a smart thermostat. Ecobee for data nerds. Nest for design lovers. Honeywell for simplicity. Thenprogram your schedule. Set away mode when you are at work. Set sleep mode higher in summer. Alsoenable geofencing. Let the thermostat know when you leave and return. Finallyclaim the 25C tax credit. Save your receipt. Watt and Volt do not care about smart thermostats. They care about the warm spot on the floor where the sun hits. My Ecobee saved me $58 a month. That is a year of free electricity for my fridge. Not bad.

8 Smart Thermostats Compared: Features and Savings

Recommended Tools

Ryan Mitchell

Related Articles

Recommended Tools

Ryan Mitchell